Tailgate Blogs

Share your news, stories and general randomness with the Tailgate365 community!
mindpinball

Being a fan is a serious business. Many fans are and should be passionate about their favorite team.  But what differentiates a passionate fan from a homer?

In a post inspired by a comment conversation I saw recently at  The NFL Chick blog (check her out ya'll), she explained to me how she was called a "homer" by Ed The Sports Fan (don't sleep on him either), because in her post about running back tandems to take notice of, she included one from her team and mine, the Baltimore Ravens. As a fellow fan of the Ravens, I've got to have her back on this one. The "three-headed monster" was a force last season for the Ravens, and I don't see any reason why they can't be as good or better, even without Lorenzo Neal blocking. But does the fact that she even included Willis McGahee and Ray Rice make her a homer? I told her that I didn't think so, that being a homer means that you drink the kool-aid no matter what, even in the face of evidence to suggest otherwise. I'd say that she falls on the passionate fan side of the ledger.

To me, a homer is someone who roots for the home team but doesn't give the other team any credit if they come out on top over your squad.  A homer is also someone who won't admit that something the team did was wrong, but places blame on anyone or anything outside the team. By a basic definition, I would suppose that I am a homer because I root for my local teams. However, I am not someone who can't give the other team some credit when they beat my team. I am a passionate fan for the squads I like (and it ain't easy when the Orioles and Wizards are on your list). But if another team comes in and whoops my team, unless there is some egregious mistake by the team or the officiating, I can give the other team credit and admit they were better on that particular day. I can also criticize my team if they make a personnel decision I don't agree with, or a player who doesn't make a play at a crucial time. In the history of sports, every team has made a mistake at one time or another. To not even acknowledge any mistake or error by your team or its management puts you in the homer category.

Perhaps the worst type of homer is the press box homer. Now I suppose when you are hired by the team and they sign your paycheck, you have to "root" for the home team some. But the motto used to be "no cheering in the press box" (or at least I think it still is). The good announcers can support the home team without being overzealous about it. One of the rumors as to why John Miller was sent packing as the Orioles radio announcer years ago was because Peter Angelos didn't think he rooted for the Orioles enough and was too critical of them when the team made mistakes. Now, I've always thought that Miller broadcast the right way...but I can remember watching Atlanta Braves games back in the day when Skip Caray would root for the Braves unashamedly from announcer's booth, often invoking "we" as in "we (the Braves) need to score some runs." I was never a fan of that style of announcing, but some fans may like it. To me though, Carey was a homer.

If you have an opinion on this, let me know in the comments.


Trackback(0)
Comments (5)Add Comment
MyLobotomy
...
written by MyLobotomy, July 07, 2009
The press box homers are really annoying. I watch a lot of Nuggets hoops and while I like Scott Hastings, he is a bad homer. Sometimes I have to turn the volume down.

Personally I'm a homer and I admit it.
Lee
...
written by Lee, July 11, 2009
As far as announcer homers, none was better than Harry Carey. He loved his Cubbies and was unapologetic about wanting them to win.
mindpinball
...
written by tws392000, July 13, 2009
Presumably that's where Skip got his homer announcer genes...Never got to watch any Cub games with Harry at the mike, so I can only go on what I read, but saw plenty of Braves games when they tried to be America's baseball team and I thought he was horrible.
ptrain86
...
written by ptrain86, July 14, 2009
Passionate fan here. I criticize my home team and players all the time... mostly the management though. To be a Brewer and Packer fan for so long and see multiple decades of losing makes it easier to be a little more negative/bitter. Though, I feel that fantasy leagues have given me a better appreciation of other teams and their players to give them more credit than my teams sucking as well. Many announcers do drive me nuts, especially those that put in their two cents, but really don't follow the team and really don't have a clue.
Lee
...
written by Lee, July 14, 2009
A weird one for me is Rob Dibble. He is now an announcer for the Nationals and to hear him saying "we" all the time is strange.

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy